October 2, 2025 | portfolio managers' brief

Portfolio Managers’ Brief: September 2025

BY: Jason Ayres
Key Takeaways U.S. Market Leadership Canadian Market Momentum Index Performance (YTD) (September 25th , 2025) Valuation Concerns Fed Chair Powell’s Caution Technical Indicators Small-Cap Risks Central Bank Shifts Labour Market Cooling U.S. Canada Inflation & Policy Outlook Portfolio Positioning Final Thoughts

SHARE IT ONLINE:


Key Takeaways

U.S. Market Leadership

  • Year-to-date gains remain heavily concentrated in mega-cap technology, particularly the “Magnificent Seven.”
  • Alphabet, Nvidia, and Microsoft have been primary drivers, supported by strong earnings and Fed easing expectations.
  • Market breadth remains narrow, raising concerns about sustainability.

Canadian Market Momentum

  • TSX Composite has rebounded strongly, up ~20% YTD, outperforming major U.S. indices.
  • Financials and energy are leading sectors, helped by softening inflation and labour market data.
  • Early Bank of Canada rate cuts have provided an additional tailwind.

Index Performance (YTD) (September 25th , 2025)

  • TSX Composite: +20% (best-performing major North American index).
  • Nasdaq 100: +15.3%.
  • S&P 500: +11.8%.
  • Dow Jones: +8.0%.

Valuation Concerns

  • S&P 500 trading at ~23.5× forward earnings, back to 2024 highs.
  • Equal-weighted S&P also elevated at 17.7×.
  • Technology, especially the Magnificent Seven, trades at ~35× earnings.
  • Narrow leadership historically increases correction risk.

Fed Chair Powell’s Caution

  • Powell remarked that equity prices are “fairly highly valued” (Sept. 23).
  • His comments triggered profit-taking as investors reconsidered stretched valuations.

Technical Indicators

  • S&P 500 appears overbought across daily, weekly, and monthly timeframes.
  • RSI readings above 70 flag stretched conditions that could lead to volatility.

Small-Cap Risks

  • Russell 2000 rallying on rate-cut optimism, but fundamentals remain weak.
  • High leverage, shorter debt maturities, and low profitability make broad exposure risky.
  • Selectivity is essential in small-cap allocations.

Central Bank Shifts

  • Fed cut rates by 25 bps in September; signaled another cut this year.
  • BoC also cut 25 bps, bringing rates to 2.5% (lowest in 3 years).
  • Both signal further gradual easing if growth softens.

Labour Market Cooling

U.S.

  • Payrolls up only 22,000 in August; unemployment rose to 4.3% (4-year high).
  • Job growth averaging 27,000/month vs. prior strength.

Canada

  • 100,000+ jobs lost in July–August; unemployment up to 7.1%.
  • Losses broad-based across sectors, adding pressure for further BoC easing.

Inflation & Policy Outlook

  • U.S. CPI: 2.9% y/y in August; core remains sticky.
  • Canada CPI: 1.9% y/y; more room for BoC to ease.
  • Divergence: U.S. core inflation may limit Fed cuts, while Canada has more flexibility.

Portfolio Positioning

  • Trimmed equity exposure; ~5% cash raised for flexibility.
  • Remain selective in tech/communications due to stretched valuations.
  • Favor high-quality fixed income for defense and stability.
  • CFG Income Fund: maintaining put-writing strategy on U.S. Treasuries.

Final Thoughts

  • Markets remain resilient but leadership is narrow and valuations stretched.
  • Labour markets weakening adds risk to the outlook.
  • Expect higher volatility ahead as rate cuts are balanced against slowing growth.
  • Focus remains on capital preservation, selective equity exposure, and defensive fixed income positioning.

related posts

Portfolio Managers’ Brief: November 2025
Portfolio Managers’ Brief: November 2025

Portfolio Managers’ Brief: November 2025

Key Takeaways November 2025 Markets at New Highs, But Leadership Is Narrow North American equities hit new highs on cooler inflation and resilient Q3 earnings, but gains are increasingly concentrated in select sectors and mega-cap names. Day-to-day moves are being driven more by central bank messaging than the rate cuts themselves. Index Scorecard (YTD Snapshot) […]